View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0012350Return of ReckoningGeneralpublic2023-12-09 15:20
ReporterReturnOfReckoning Assigned To 
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityhave not tried
Status closedResolutionopen 
Summary0012350: [RvR] Remove Keep Doors - stuck exploit.
DescriptionReporter: XmatXergon

ITS VERY IMPORTANT ISSUE - game breaking/exploiting.

Expected behavior and actual behavior:
Not getting stuck after pull from Engi/Magus/Choppa in Keep Doors after doors gets opened even though enemy who is pulling you, don't have Line of Sight on you (nature of AoE ability).
At the moment some ppl who know how that ability works exploit it and pull enemies to make them stuck in doors. Yes, it is an exploiting, because if they were standing with their Tanks between doors, that would not happen, but instead they move behind doors and keep trying to pull enemies through the doors, into doors.

You can even see exactly who are the choppas that position themselves to exploit that bug.

I see only 2 possible solutions, either removing doors completely after they getting destroyed or fix pull in a way, where the pulling character can't pull target on which they don't have Line of Sight.

Steps to reproduce the problem:
Get class like Magus / Engineer / Choppa and after doors getting opened setup on spots marked on screenshot below, specially place where doors connect with wall, and pull enemy in front of doors (outside keep).
![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907867-077e6e00-bdfa-11e8-8225-2d2cd7609406.png)

Screenshots/Videos or archive.org evidences:
Below i provide screenshots from live fights:
![xergov_072](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907960-84a9e300-bdfa-11e8-85e5-9a474ac3fd56.jpg)
![xergov_071](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907961-84a9e300-bdfa-11e8-972d-14a67ee8297e.jpg)
![xergov_070](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907962-84a9e300-bdfa-11e8-97ed-255c59feb0e7.jpg)
![xergov_069](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907964-85427980-bdfa-11e8-9b56-237332554245.jpg)
![xergov_068](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907965-85427980-bdfa-11e8-862a-a4357dcba06e.jpg)
![xergov_067](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907966-85427980-bdfa-11e8-8891-e0d6d2ff4ba4.jpg)
![xergov_066](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907967-85427980-bdfa-11e8-9fa4-6be8ba40d6fd.jpg)
![xergov_065](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907968-85427980-bdfa-11e8-89b5-a6f8f5a0bd0c.jpg)
![xergov_064](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907969-85427980-bdfa-11e8-8f0d-5270502d5082.jpg)
![xergov_063](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907970-85db1000-bdfa-11e8-84cc-bc1b6ec5cbbe.jpg)
![xergov_062](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907971-85db1000-bdfa-11e8-8885-e2490f16a013.jpg)
![xergov_060](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907973-85db1000-bdfa-11e8-89a6-87920d679ce0.jpg)
![xergov_059](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907974-85db1000-bdfa-11e8-8766-009cf8f02ede.jpg)
![xergov_061](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45907972-85db1000-bdfa-11e8-9490-e37e9a483f69.jpg)

Some even got stuck in doors after fight end like here:
![xergov_074](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/45908226-c12a0e80-bdfb-11e8-8d81-18ad931b19e4.jpg)

TagsAbility, Known Issue - Review again., Sourcecode

Activities

ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022104

Commenter: Gideon404

Could also make the doors no-collision once opened.
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022105

Commenter: sioding

Thanks for the report but i am sorry - this is not a bug. The abilities are working fine - the doors are working fine. All is see is a suggestion to improve the gameplay inside a keep. Since the bugtracker is not the best place for it - i would kindly ask you to bring that in our "Suggestion & Feedback" part of the forum: https://www.returnofreckoning.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=15
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022106

Commenter: Natherul

if players do in fact get stuck due to the pull then it belongs here. Doors will not be removed but we can see if we can make attempts at fixing the pulls
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022107

Commenter: XmatXergon

Thanks Natherul.
Someone suggested on forums that also maybe make doors as non-obstacle object but idk if thats better. There are not issues in Elf lands because there are no doors after they got destroyed.

On screens number 3 and 4 (from bottom) you can see that i'm still alive but i get message in chat about Stuck.
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022108

Commenter: Natherul

making doors not cause collision is imho a worse solution. I would sooner look into the pull abilities themselves
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022109

Commenter: sioding

Fixed with patch from 29.09.2018
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022110

Commenter: XmatXergon

Still getting stuck:
![xergov_080](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/46263805-44daae00-c514-11e8-810e-3bda4235b5dc.jpg)
![xergov_081](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/46263807-46a47180-c514-11e8-88e2-22d7ec85dd7e.jpg)
![xergov_082](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/46263808-486e3500-c514-11e8-91c3-19dbb0ec3f4a.jpg)
![xergov_084](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/46263810-4a37f880-c514-11e8-869f-a16b991c0f7f.jpg)
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022111

Commenter: sioding

reopened
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022112

Commenter: XmatXergon

![xergok_019](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/37849311/47580777-0dfb8a80-d950-11e8-8a97-5ebd5ecc7e79.jpg)
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022113

Commenter: Natherul

Looked over GTDC just now and it does respect LOS (has for a very long time). Issue is that the doors themselves in this case does not appear to block LOS as it is right now. However removing the door is not an option.
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022114

Commenter: XmatXergon

So is there way for doors to make them block LOS ?
Or atleast after doors go down, treat it like solid object/wall ?
Its only problem in Empire keeps, it doesnt happen in Elf or Dwarf zones.
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022115

Commenter: Evilmariel

Adding this in here as it can relate to Door LoS & Pull issue; video on engineer pulling from inside Bugmans Brewery in Black Fire Pass.

https://youtu.be/WBpAbNGQ2Yg
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 03:41

reporter   ~0022116

Commenter: Natherul

that is a different issue that will be fixed with next patch. The doors that dont calculate LOS will remain an issue for a while I imagine however.
MaxHayman

MaxHayman

2023-12-09 15:20

administrator   ~0041308

This issue is being closed as it should be fixed in the new ability system. Please create a new issue if this is not the case.

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning New Issue
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Tag Attached: Ability
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Tag Attached: Sourcecode
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Tag Attached: Known Issue - Review again.
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022104
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022105
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022106
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022107
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022108
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022109
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022110
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022111
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022112
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022113
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022114
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022115
2023-08-13 03:41 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0022116
2023-12-09 15:20 MaxHayman Note Added: 0041308
2023-12-09 15:20 MaxHayman Status new => closed