View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0020047Return of ReckoningGeneralpublic2023-08-13 04:33
ReporterReturnOfReckoning Assigned To 
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityhave not tried
Status newResolutionopen 
Summary0020047: Main crafting material not consumed on critical success?
DescriptionReporter: JohnnyWayne89

Hi guys,

I might have stumbled over an issue, I can't confirm 100%. I got two epic armor crafting materials yesterday (as far as i know). I created one armor talisman last night with a critical success and for some reason i still had two crafting materials after creating it. The relic talisman box was gone though. Either I got a thrid one and missed it, cirtical successes don't consume the main material for armor talismans or the item was somehow dulicated. I thought maybe someone wants to check in the database if something wonky happened. Please don't ban me Q__Q.

I noticed that I was missing HP from the renown rank trainer (had 8500 HP but should have had around 8800), so maybe its related to another issue.

If you want to look into this and the item was actually duplicated I can just delete the duplicate, no problem.

**Expected behavior and actual behavior:**
Crafting material i usually consumed during item creation.

**Steps to reproduce the problem:**
Not completly sure. Create an 136 armor talisman with max materials, get a critical success procc. Maybe also related to an bug that does not award all the renown trainer stats to your character.

Edit: Oh right, what do you require to identify the character?
TagsCrafting

Activities

ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 04:33

reporter   ~0037647

Commenter: JohnnyWayne89

Advice chat told me I might have duped it but a guild mate confirmed my initial suspicion: Some lucky proccs just don't consume materials. If so please just close the ticket.
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 04:33

reporter   ~0037648

Commenter: lilimx

Hey,

Dod you know where you've got the materials? Additonal you can post your Character-Name aswell.
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 04:33

reporter   ~0037649

Commenter: JohnnyWayne89

Got them in a gunbad run the same day. Server was somewhat wonky earlier but no issues during that run (they were rebooted earlier). Character is Delenda. I crafted the talisman around 2 am today (CET).
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 04:33

reporter   ~0037650

Commenter: Zomega-WAR

For what it's worth, I can confirm that crit talisman making on 200 purple fragements doesn't consume the fragment (I can't remember if the other materials are consumed, and I don't know about other fragments as I only use 200 purples). I had assumed this was by design as I can't remember a time when it didn't work this way on ROR.

I cannot remember how it worked on live.
ReturnOfReckoning

ReturnOfReckoning

2023-08-13 04:33

reporter   ~0037651

Commenter: Zomega-WAR

https://warhammerfantasy.fandom.com/wiki/Hammerwiki:Talisman_Making

There's 2 kinds of crits:

1) critical success ("You made something better!") - this improves the stats on the talisman
2) super-critical success ("You made something awesome!") - this increases the rarity of the talisman/fragment (white becomes green, green becomes blue, blue becomes purple). As there is nothing higher than purple, instead the fragment is not consumed.

So the fragment not being consumed on a super crit seems to be intended as per how it worked on live.

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
2023-08-13 04:33 ReturnOfReckoning New Issue
2023-08-13 04:33 ReturnOfReckoning Tag Attached: Crafting
2023-08-13 04:33 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0037647
2023-08-13 04:33 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0037648
2023-08-13 04:33 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0037649
2023-08-13 04:33 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0037650
2023-08-13 04:33 ReturnOfReckoning Note Added: 0037651