View Issue Details
ID | Project | Category | View Status | Date Submitted | Last Update |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
0023661 | Return of Reckoning | General | public | 2024-11-30 07:54 | 2024-12-08 18:11 |
Reporter | R1CH | Assigned To | Natherul | ||
Priority | normal | Severity | minor | Reproducibility | have not tried |
Status | resolved | Resolution | fixed | ||
Summary | 0023661: Victory Point system for zone lock rewards not working correctly | ||||
Description | Based on Praag tonight, there are several issues with the new zone rewards system: - Permanent contribution from kills to the zone doesn't seem to be counted at all. Praag started at 10% and reached a peak of 22%, however after a trip to take another zone Praag was back at 10%. - Recent kills contribution seems too low. There were over 3800 kills over an 8 hour period, including a period with 3-4 WBs on both sides and almost 1000 kills in an hour. At no time did the VP system go above 22%. - Recent kills contribution decays too quickly. After reaching 22% I expected the number to keep increasing as the fights continued, instead it slowly dropped to 20%, then 15% over the course of 30-60 minutes, even as fighting continued. By the time order was ready to ram it had dropped back to 10%. I was in a WB with around 750 kills by the end of the zone, the reward was 3 war crests and 1352 renown (this is including +25% pot and +20% from the event). Being a BW, I should have received double crests for locking the Empire pairing, so 3 crests suggest this bonus might not be happening. If this reward was 10% of the maximum possible, it also seems much lower than the old system - I would typically expect 20-25k renown and 60-80 crests for such an active zone lock. | ||||
Additional Information | Skirmishes: https://killboard.returnofreckoning.com/skirmish/3b7d2905875d4776b81adad71a54eb56 https://killboard.returnofreckoning.com/skirmish/cbb84b6f63b348d4b693155b13f37f65 | ||||
Tags | No tags attached. | ||||
|
|
Im hesitant to close this ticket just yet but we think its been fixed with the hotfix this morning (from my experience today it seems to be fixed at least) Do note the extra notes in the hotfix as of this morning as part of the system has changed, |
|
Rewards still seem bugged and much lower than expected. VP-wise, things looked good, there was a big fight tonight in Eataine that reached 100% VP pretty easily and stayed there, but the rewards still felt off. I was solo and received 3 crests and 1k renown for the zone lock after 3 hours of fighting (39 kills, multiple boxes, BO captures, participation in siege). People in a WB with 700+ kills also reported low rewards of around 2.5k renown and 4 - 6 crests. Skirmish: https://killboard.returnofreckoning.com/skirmish/3c34973154304d138c321e029ae8c366 |
|
I'm not sure if today's hotfix changed something, but had what I consider too high of a reward now in TC on an Empire char. I logged in just as the siege started and only managed to get a deathblow on a few low levels. I turned in around 3-4 boxes and did not even get a hit on the lord and received 39 crests and 10k renown for less than 20 minutes of playtime. Others in the zone who were there much longer than me reported much lower rewards. There were similar reports in the following zone. Is it possible the contribution calculation is inverted? | |
I dont think so but we can have a look if you tell me what character you were playing at and around what time that was as we added extra logging for the rewards. That said assuming you had 100% VP in the zone you had about a 50% contribution share by the sounds of things. Do note that late last night we found some more issues with the system that has pending changes in where VP was wrongly reset just before dealing out rewards. |
|
I was on Bronag tonight, TC locked around 2230 server time and HP around 0115, I felt I did not have much contribution in those zones but got fairly good rewards. Praag and Shadowlands rewards seemed normal however, so there doesn't seem to be any kind of pattern to it. | |
Late update but we are monitoring it and it seems like VP and rewards for zonelocks are now working (as of latest hotfix) as intended but Ill keep it open for a while more. | |
Not entirely related to the VP system, but I think zone rewards are now taking AAO into account (I don't believe they used to). I got over 30k for losing a zone (granted, I had lots of +renown going on, but still...) | |
this is intended. However, we have seen some issues with calculation of AAO/Apathy whivh we are looking into | |
There was a big fight tonight in KV (https://killboard.returnofreckoning.com/skirmish/56241659319345a0859903bfc6426b01) which easily maxed out the VP at 100%, but an attempt at sieging failed. The battles moved to other zones for 2-3 hours, when we came back the VP had reset to 10%. If there's still permanent contribution to the zone then it looks like it is being lost somewhere (keep defense tick?) |
|
There are 2 parts in rewards, personal contribution and VP. Personal contributions does not expire but you cannot see it. VP does expire as its the kills and pop in the sone over the last 2 hours. So what you are describing sounds correct to me. I should add that all logs (at least as of yesterday when I looked last) seem to reward people correct now based on both the VP and the personal contributions they have. |
|
Got it, thanks for the explanation. Based on that then everything I've seen over the last few days looks pretty good now in T4, T2/T3 will probably be good too once the population/AAO issue is fixed. | |
T2/3 rewards seems to be good when I checked the logs as well however there is a bug as you mentioned with the counting which is the root cause for AAO, apathy, SOR, lords health and VP generation. We are trying to find that bug still however its elusive as it seems to work anytime we try locally. (But we have observed it on live and it seems to either only happen in T2-3 or at the very least happen way less in T4). However that is a separate bug from this even if it ties together somewhat. | |
It all seems to work as it should now so Ill mark this as fixed. We are also monitoring it in the background still. Should you see more issues please open a new ticket or reopen this one. | |
Date Modified | Username | Field | Change |
---|---|---|---|
2024-11-30 07:54 | R1CH | New Issue | |
2024-11-30 07:54 | R1CH | File Added: praaglock.jpg | |
2024-11-30 07:54 | R1CH | File Added: IIGuTgabmw.png | |
2024-11-30 07:54 | R1CH | File Added: NYV4XpWTQc.png | |
2024-12-01 02:52 | Emissary | Assigned To | => Natherul |
2024-12-01 02:52 | Emissary | Status | new => assigned |
2024-12-01 16:18 | Natherul | Note Added: 0045553 | |
2024-12-03 04:03 | R1CH | Note Added: 0045580 | |
2024-12-04 00:17 | R1CH | Note Added: 0045588 | |
2024-12-04 00:17 | R1CH | File Added: FT3ljF7G2Z.png | |
2024-12-04 06:31 | Natherul | Note Added: 0045590 | |
2024-12-04 06:54 | R1CH | Note Added: 0045591 | |
2024-12-05 16:58 | Natherul | Note Added: 0045600 | |
2024-12-06 01:22 | R1CH | Note Added: 0045628 | |
2024-12-06 04:24 | Natherul | Note Added: 0045637 | |
2024-12-07 06:36 | R1CH | Note Added: 0045666 | |
2024-12-07 06:49 | Natherul | Note Added: 0045667 | |
2024-12-07 06:56 | R1CH | Note Added: 0045668 | |
2024-12-07 06:59 | Natherul | Note Added: 0045669 | |
2024-12-08 18:11 | Natherul | Status | assigned => resolved |
2024-12-08 18:11 | Natherul | Resolution | open => fixed |
2024-12-08 18:11 | Natherul | Note Added: 0045688 |